Open or Closed System Breast Pump

Is it Better to Get Open or Closed System Breast Pump?

As you’re getting ready for your baby’s arrival, you’re probably doing everything you can to prepare yourself and your home. You may be taking Lamaze classes, painting the baby’s room, or Open or closed system breast pumppicking out a crib and baby carrier. A breast pump probably wasn’t the first item on your baby checklist, but here you are researching the different types of breast pumps. One of the variations you may have come across is the open or closed system breast pump. Here at The Breastfeeding Shop, we strive to do everything we can to help new moms get the best breast pumping equipment for them and their babies. So, we want to help you make an informed decision about the breast pump that you decide on. Many insurance providers allow you to choose any type of breast pump that you want.

If you have a busy life or are planning to return to the workforce, picking the right breast pump is a very important decision for you. Even if you’re only going to pump occasionally, you still need a breast pump that you can rely on. So, you may be wondering about the differences between open and closed pumps. Let’s break down the differences between closed and open system pumps. We also have an article on manual versus electric breast pumps. Hopefully, finding the right breast pump will become a bit easier for you.

Breast Pump with a Closed System

What’s the difference between an open or closed system breast pump? In a closed system pump, there is a barrier between the actual pump parts and the breast milk. Therefore, there’s no way for milk particles to get in the various breast pump parts, contaminating it. You can have peace of mind, not having to worry about the build-up of mold or bacteria in the pump. It will remain sanitary and safe for you. Some of the best closed system pumps include the Spectra S2 and S1 and the Freemie Independence.

It’s important to note that closed or open system pumps are not medical terms. A certain breast pump manufacturer might use these terms differently than another one. And some manufacturers (like Medela) use the term overflow protection instead. This lets you know that the barrier is there to do just that — protect the pump from milk overflow.

Breast Pump with an Open System

With an open system breast pump, there is no barrier that stops the milk. So, if milk gets into the tubing, the motor, or a valve — you’ll have to clean out those parts thoroughly before the pump’s next use. Also, it’s possible that outside air contaminates (like allergens, dust, and pet dander) could get into the open system breast pump. As long as you’re cleaning the baby nursing equipment and letting it dry properly, there is little risk of contamination. Some of our best open system breast pumps include the Medela Pump In Style and the Lansinoh Signature Pro.

What’s the Best Kind of Breast Pump?

Should I get a closed or open breast pump?Open or closed system breast pump, what’s best? Closed system pumps are great, but don’t be mistaken. You do have to clean them every so often in between pumping sessions. Cleaning your breast pump is important, whether you get an open or closed system breast pump. You want to take every precaution you can to make sure that your infant is happy and healthy.

It’s important to note that every mom and baby combo is different. So, the best breast pump for your friend or sister may not be the one that’s right for you. If you have any concerns or questions about a certain model of breast pump, don’t hesitate to reach out to The Breastfeeding Shop. We want to help you get just the right pump that helps you express milk and nourish your baby. With so many different pumps on the market today, it can be really time-consuming to research all the different options. Our breast pump experts can help make this process quick and easy for you, allowing you to get back to that baby preparation checklist. And if you’re still trying to decide between an open or closed system breast pump, contact us for more information. We’re happy to help you out.